Three-win Saints, Kellen Moore face defining stretch of games

play
Saints let crucial NFC South opportunity slip away (0:40)

NEW ORLEANS -- The Saints (3-6) have a hill to climb if they want to get back to the top of the NFC South. At this point in the season, it almost feels insurmountable.

The Saints had an opportunity to secure first place in a shaky division last Sunday against the Carolina Panthers, however, they repeated many of their old mistakes, losing 20-17 after allowing two late scores.

"Obviously we had plenty of opportunities in this game. We didn't get it done," a terse Saints coach Kellen Moore said postgame, mentioning the need to "get better," four times.

But despite Moore repeating that phrase not just on Sunday but many times over the course of this rocky season, the Saints have failed to get better in key areas. Against the Panthers, New Orleans fell short in those areas again.

They didn't score points in the first quarter for the seventh time this season, an issue Saints rookie Jordyn Tyson noted Moore has "harped on," without results. They had less than 100 net rushing yards for the sixth time and had at least two turnovers for the fifth time this season.

The Saints now have an 0-2 record in the division and the feeling that they beat themselves yet again. Tight end Juwan Johnson said the Saints still believe things can be turned around, especially in a division in which no team has a winning record.

"What we could all do is to learn from it, watch the film, move forward," Johnson said of Sunday's loss. "I know it sounds like a PR answer, but that's literally what we have to do in order to move forward because we say it every year, we're only a game back."

While the Saints are only a few games out of contention now, that could easily slip away in the next few weeks. Not only do they have to account for those repeated mistakes that lost them games, but they have to fix them against some of the toughest opponents left on the schedule.

"We definitely knew [what] was at stake," Saints running back Travis Etienne Jr said. "So it wasn't like we was unaware and it definitely hurt that we didn't capitalize on that moment. Win that game, we would've had control of our own destiny. So I feel like now we're putting our faith in someone else's hands."

The next three games will be the most challenging stretch they've seen so far. The Saints will play at Chicago on Sunday (1 p.m. ET, Fox) against Dennis Allen's seventh-ranked Bears defense and at Cincinnati against the Bengals' top-ranked passing offense and top-scoring offense. Then, in Week 13, the Saints will host the Green Bay Packers, who have the second-ranked passing offense and a fourth-ranked scoring offense.

If the Saints lose all three of those games, they'll have a 3-9 record and a losing season for the second straight year under Moore. It would drop the head coach's overall record to 9-20 and a win percentage of 31%, way behind former Saints coach Mike Ditka (1997-99), who was fired after a 3-13 season in 1999 and a 15-33 coaching record in New Orleans.

Losing the next three would squarely put the team at a crossroads: Continue with a third season under Moore, or wipe the slate clean and look for their third permanent head coach since Sean Payton walked away after the 2021 season.

The Saints haven't gotten the results they expected out of Moore, who was hired after a one-year stint as the Philadelphia Eagles offensive coordinator. The Eagles had a second-ranked rushing offense and top-10 overall offense en route to a Super Bowl win.

That offensive prowess hasn't translated to New Orleans yet. The Saints have trailed in all 26 of Moore's games, and they rank last in first-quarter points scored dating to last season. Their run game ranked 28th last season (94.3 rushing yards per game) compared to 27th this season (90.1 rushing yards per game).

The organization has sent out conflicting messages about how they feel about the current state of the Saints. Owner Gayle Benson read a statement to the New Orleans Quarterback Club following a 1-4 start and a humiliating primetime loss to the Atlanta Falcons that called out both Moore and Saints general manager Mickey Loomis by name, saying the losing record was "not acceptable."

Benson sent out a public letter to fans two weeks later after the Saints rushed for 18 yards in a Week 7 loss to the Pittsburgh Steelers in Paris that appeared to soften her previous words.

"While the outcome on the field was not what we had hoped for, we have much to be proud of from our time together," she wrote. "We represented the New Orleans Saints, our beloved city and the entire state of Louisiana with class and pride on an international stage."

During the Saints Week 8 bye, Benson told WDSU-TV at a charity event that she understood the "players were working as hard as they can. You know, at the end of the season, we'll kind of look at things and see what we need to change, but for right now, I think they're going to be OK. They're going to try the best they can and that's really all they can do."

Loomis preached patience with the team during a news conference prior to the game in Paris, explaining they were excited about Tyler Shough, but said there's still a lot of development with both the second-year quarterback and the team.

Loomis said Shough was "23 games into his career with a rebuilding team" -- using the term that he was so reluctant to use as recently as last summer. Loomis has said before that "rebuild" means different things to different people because of how fast things can turn around in the course of a season.

"I think we're always in the mode of we're trying to win every game," Loomis said a few months after quarterback Derek Carr's sudden retirement in May 2025. "I don't look at it as a rebuild even though we might say we got a lot of positions of development, I should say. We've got a lot of young players that we want to develop and I'm excited about that but at the same time, look, there's always an opportunity for things to fall in place and be successful."

Whether the Saints truly think the roster needs to be rebuilt would likely influence the length of time Moore is given to turn things around. So far, aside from a few scattered wins, the Saints haven't shown any consistent trend toward that goal in the past two seasons.

Saints rookie wide receiver Jordyn Tyson was asked after the Panthers game if the players had confidence in Moore to put the offense in a position to be successful.

"Yeah, I know for 100% certainty Kellen watches, like, a lot of tape," Tyson said. "He watches through every game, last year's games, the year before that, he watches a lot of tape and I can promise you that he's giving ... his best shot."

Is Moore the right person to coach going forward? The next three games will likely tell the tale. By the end of that stretch, the Saints will either be 6-6 and still in contention for the playoffs, or they'll be mulling over their next big steps for the future.

That starts with the Bears (and Allen, the former Saints coach), in a few days.

"Ultimately we all want the same thing. We all have the same goals and aspirations, want to win football games and put ourselves in position to have success," Moore said. "Now we really have to focus on eyes forward, getting better every day."