With nine games left, is Sirianni the right coach to lead down-and-out Eagles?

play
Rich Eisen marvels at Giants-Eagles QB matchup in Week 9 (1:58)

Philadelphia Eagles coach Nick Sirianni sat in the cramped visitors interview room at Northwest Stadium late Sunday night, his arms leaning on the table and eyes looking heavy following a 27-10 Week 8 loss to the Washington Commanders that extended his team's losing streak to six games.

He puffed out his cheeks and slowly exhaled when fielding a question about end-of-half sequences that had favored the opposition the past two weeks. Situational football has long been a point of emphasis for Sirianni but in this moment he skipped over the finer details to acknowledge the bigger picture.

"I don't think we've been real sharp at any sequence at this particular time," he said. "I think that's just a product of what we have been throughout."

At 2-6, the season has gotten away from the Eagles. Between quarterback Jalen Hurts being on injured reserve with blood clots in his lungs, right tackle Lane Johnson's sudden retirement in early October and a host of injuries on both sides of the ball, hope for a turnaround is in short supply.

There are nine games remaining, starting Sunday against the division-leading New York Giants (1 p.m. ET, Fox), in what feels like a slow march toward an offseason that could usher in significant change. The debate is well underway as to whether Sirianni will be swept up in that change or the one overseeing it.

Eagles chairman and CEO Jeffrey Lurie has much to consider.

Every day he walks into the front entrance of the Jefferson Health Training Complex, he sees the two Vince Lombardi Trophies displayed in glass and knows his current head coach delivered one of them.

The Eagles made the playoffs in each of his first five seasons, went to the Super Bowl twice and became champions during the 2024 season. He entered the 2026 season with the third-highest career winning percentage (.694) in the Super Bowl era (minimum 50 games) behind only John Madden (.759) and Vince Lombardi (.738).

"I've always felt nothing but complete support from Mr. Lurie in everything," Sirianni said Wednesday, when asked what his communication with Lurie has been like during the losing streak. "Through good times, through bad times, that's huge to know the owner has your back in all situations."

Lurie is also financially incentivized to keep Sirianni around. He signed Sirianni to a multiyear contract extension in May 2025 that industry sources believe to be around $15 million annually.

Sirianni has shown malleability. His decision to hand over playcalling duties to Shane Steichen in 2021 helped spark a turnaround, as the 2-5 Eagles rallied to a 9-8 record and made the playoffs. When the offense sagged in the beginning of 2024, he leaned into Saquon Barkley and the ground game and rode it all the way to a world title.

Asked how Sirianni has handled this most recent slide, Barkley said, "I'm not taking a shot at any coach I've had before but I've been in situations where the season is not going the way you want it to go and you don't always get the same man every single time."

Barkley learned the value of being a steady presence during his lean years in New York, taking cues from guys such as Eli Manning and Dexter Lawrence II and said "Nick is that to a 'T.' Has he ramped it up a little bit more? Is there a little bit more of a sense of urgency? Of course, yes, because that's needed. But I really take my hat off to him because I know it can go the other way."

There have been instances, though, of the team spiraling under Sirianni's stewardship. The 2023 campaign is the most obvious. The cracks in the foundation began showing themselves in the latter stages of the season and a 10-1 team dropped six of their last seven, including a 32-9 shellacking at the hands of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in the wild-card round of the playoffs.

With the on-field relationship between Hurts and A.J. Brown fraying, they lost five of their last eight in 2025 and were bounced in the wild-card round at home against the San Francisco 49ers.

In good years and bad, there has been a decent amount of tumult behind the scenes, and it has been a mixed bag for Sirianni in his attempts to maintain a positive culture through adversity.

Then there's this season. Sirianni and the Eagles have been dealt a bad hand but with the talent still remaining, should they really have the worst record in the NFC?

The offense, working under first-year coordinator Sean Mannion, ranks 30th in points per game (17.1), 28th in offensive efficiency (31.53) and 31st in first downs per game (16.1). The defense has not come close to meeting expectations, ranking 27th in efficiency (42.51), 26th in EPA (-30.68) and tied for last in opponent sacks per dropback (3.4%).

Players on both sides of the ball have pointed to effort or "want-to" as not being up to snuff.

The passing game in particular has been substandard for the past three-plus years. Just as it had in 2023, the offensive attack grew stale last season to the point that the offensive coordinator was fired and a new one was brought in to freshen up the scheme. The change from Brian Johnson to Kellen Moore worked (once they dedicated themselves to the ground game) while the switch from Kevin Patullo to Mannion has borne little fruit to this point.

The success of the offense has appeared tied to whether the organization hits on its OC choice, even though Sirianni has an offensive background. This has created a roller-coaster effect as Hurts has worked with six different playcallers during his five-plus seasons with Sirianni.

Barring a significant turnaround, there's a good chance they'll have yet another playcaller overseeing the offense in 2027. From his health to his contract, there's much to sort through when it comes to Hurts' future. If he's back, is the right course of action to keep him in this playcalling turnover spin cycle?

The same question applies if the Eagles go in a different direction at quarterback, whether by selecting a QB high in April's draft or otherwise. Coordinators get promoted and let go all across the league -- it's the nature of the business -- but if your head coach is the architect of the scheme, it increases the likelihood of offensive continuity and can reduce the feeling of volatility.

Sirianni has proved to be a good match for this heavily involved front office. He focuses on coaching and is comfortable with general manager Howie Roseman doing his thing on the personnel and operations side.

Roseman has fielded arguably the most talented team in football during Sirianni's time in Philadelphia and Sirianni, aided by a top-shelf coaching staff as well, has shepherded those teams to incredible highs, the occasional sideways season notwithstanding.

This year has presented Sirianni with a unique challenge where health and talent have not been there in the same abundance. He has had to deal with the loss of his quarterback, the retirement of his stalwart right tackle, and the trade of starting center Cam Jurgens. The team began its freefall in late September and is still dropping all these weeks later.

When the conditions are poor, is Sirianni the right man for the job? It's an important question not just for now but the immediate future given that a quick roster fix might not be in the offing.

That brings us to those last nine games. Every coach is entitled to a down season or two, especially someone such as Sirianni whose achievements should come with a certain amount of equity. But this season has felt more like 2012 and 2015 and 2020, the final years for Reid, Chip Kelly and Doug Pederson, respectively, where the operation feels flat and the players aren't responding and change appears to be in the air.

With more than half of a season to go, Sirianni will either get this team to respond or he won't. Either way, Lurie will be watching.