Overreact much? The really regrettable thing about Sandpapergate is Cricket Australia's response to it

Usman Khawaja and Pat Cummins look on from the dugout Quinn Rooney / © Getty Images

"I am satisfied that the sanctions in this case properly reflect a balance between the need to protect the integrity and reputation of the game, and the need to maintain the possibility of redemption for the individuals involved, all of whom have learned difficult lessons through these events."

So said James Sutherland, then CEO of Cricket Australia, in March 2018, having announced year-long bans for Steve Smith and David Warner, and a nine-month one for Cameron Bancroft, as the afters of Cape Town. It hadn't even been a week since Bancroft was caught with sandpaper in his pocket but CA had completed its investigation, closed the book, and was shepherding people along because there was nothing more to see here.

"Redemption" struck me then as an especially revelatory - even inflammatory - word in that word salad; a needless moral inflection speaking entirely to the hysteria of that moment rather than the nature of the actual transgression. One might seek redemption for any number of sins, but ball-tampering? That's breaking law 41.3, not a religious or moral code. Or at least it hardly was at the time. It happened, players got caught, copped punishments and moved on. Some like Faf du Plessis got done caught twice and, on last sighting, he seemed in little need of redeeming.

The first time du Plessis was caught in 2013 - remember, Zippergate preceded both Mint and Sandpaper - I'd argued for the spiritual decriminalisation of ball-tampering. It was a legal transgression, a low-grade misdemeanour that was a natural by-product of highly and ruthlessly competitive sport. I recall it only because the view remains unchanged. And relevant.

Because the real and enduring lament of Sandpapergate has always been to do with CA's overreaction, the first snowballing into the latest: the independent forum where those involved can come and privately share their experiences, recollections and feelings about what, presumably, really went down. It's well-meaning no doubt. Just that it sounds like a Truth and Reconciliation Committee for - I feel I need to repeat - ball-tampering.

In any case, I wonder what Sutherland makes of this last fortnight. The investigation's findings have not aged well and neither has that redemption been forthcoming. There has been release for some, yes, not least from the tyrannies of the narrative imposed by the investigation, which somehow concluded that only Smith, Warner and Bancroft were culpable. That always seemed the least truthful outcome, an interim truth that needed to hold until the real truth finally came out.

Which - even as multiple truths have jousted with each other these last two weeks - we appear unmistakably to be heading towards. In announcing the forum, the current CEO, Todd Greenberg, acknowledged the several truths that have emerged. They can all be true, he said. "My version of events might be different to yours. They can be true to you and to me. That's the difficulty."

Like the forum, Greenberg's words are also well-intentioned, said in a difficult situation, and more so because it is not a situation of his making. But when two sets of truths stand in such open opposition and contradiction to each other; when one bunch of players says everyone knew and another bunch says everyone didn't know, then they can't all be true. Perspectives and recollections can differ but not the core truth. These truths cannot co-exist. The earth, for instance, cannot be both round and flat.

Until Bancroft said his piece, it didn't feel like we were choosing from competing truths as much as being asked to pick a favourite child. Both Khawaja and Cummins are immense figures in the modern Australian cricket story. They became Australian cricketers almost contemporaneously, debuting the same year - Cummins' first Test was Khawaja's fourth. By the time of Cape Town, both could claim life had been lifing: Khawaja, 31, was in his second comeback, playing his 32nd Test; Cummins, 24, was only in his 13th, a year into his return from a six-year layoff.

And now their truths. On one side, the account of Khawaja, a man who forged a pioneering and unique cricket career in Australia. On the other, Cummins, an all-time fast bowler, and the captain responsible for the rare feat of making a great Australian cricket side a likeable one. In one corner a confessional chapter from the punchy, raw memoir of a player opening himself up to the world. In the other, an indefatigable, unparalleled 68-minute press conference by a player opening himself up to a media inquisition. For the binary bloodthirst of the social media life we live now, a gift.

But Bancroft's intervention, triggered by Cummins' press conference and spurred by CA's truth forum, has the feel of something definitive, and decisive. It is brave and vulnerable and enlightening. Coming from a man who long ago knew he had no chance at recovering what he had lost - the one thing that was dearest to him - the nearly 4000 words come with undeniable heft and authenticity. And as with the chapter in Khawaja's book, also that tangible sense of release.

But the specificity of some of what Bancroft describes carries its own evidentiary weight. Such as the team's awareness of gaps in broadcast-camera movements, which would allow tampering to go uncaptured. Or his recollection of regular on-field conversations with the bowlers and keeper to see if his work was having the desired impact on the ball. Of course the newbie in charge of the ball would ask how the ball was doing because really, he was asking how he was doing.

It's not much but he leaves the teensiest bit of plausible deniability for Cummins and the bowlers with this one sentence: "I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used." It's not much at all, but it is not a courtesy he extends to the coaches, Darren Lehmann and David Saker.

Two other details stick. One, Kate Hutchison, the team's media manager, openly objecting in a meeting to what was going on. It must take something to stand up as a woman in a male-dominated environment, not least when said environment is a professional sports dressing room. And then imagine how much it would have taken to stand up in that particular dressing room, given all we know about the culture and environment of that team and time.

The other concerns Smith, the abstainer to Hutchison's objector, and is a more curious one (a penny for his current thoughts, by the way). Having been rumbled, Smith insisted on addressing the media that very day (where they ended up being untruthful about the object used). "Steve just wanted to clear it so he could focus on batting," writes Bancroft.

So he could focus on his batting. Any conventional and logical read of this would cast Smith's response as completely tone-deaf, a gross misreading of the room. And it tracks perfectly with Smith's reputation as a total batting wonk, wholly and weirdly consumed by it. His world is burning around him and he wants to make sure his trigger movements are in sync?

But that's to judge it post-hoc, knowing what we now know about the public overreaction and CA's pandering to it. Whereas actually in that sentence lies a tantalising parallel universe in which it is CA and the Australian public, and not Smith, who have read the room wrong. In which the fate of Smith's counterpart in that series, as well as many others before for similar misdemeanours, is the path ahead. Cricketers who, sans fuss, did "clear it" and swiftly proceeded to focus on their cricket and in which universe the sky didn't fall, and over eight years later isn't still falling.