Since the Perth Test of November 2024, KL Rahul and Yashasvi Jaiswal have played in all 18 of India's Test matches. They are India's most prolific batters in this period, with 1359 and 1290 runs respectively. Rahul has the higher average - 46.86 to 41.61 - but when you take out run-outs - Jaiswal has three and Rahul none - and compare their averages for the pure contest of ball vs bat, they're almost identical: 46.86 and 46.07.
These two batters have arrived at these remarkably similar records in remarkably contrasting ways. It's not just that one bats right-handed and the other left, and it isn't just that one tends to play more shots than the other, but their very conception of opening the batting, as borne out by their control percentages for this period: Rahul has gone at 87.55, and Jaiswal at 80.63.
Rahul, over a long and winding career of many highs and lows, has arrived at a method that prizes control. He's probably the world's finickiest judge of what to play at outside off stump: his trademark leave is the play-leave, a late withdrawal of a defensive bat from the line of the ball. And he's one of the world's most beautiful square and cover-drivers, but on most days he'll wait for the ball to be right under his eye to play the shot.
Jaiswal doesn't bat like Rahul. It's not that he bats in a contrasting way necessarily. He can bat in different tempos that vary from pitch to pitch, opposition to opposition, and situation to situation. Sometimes they seem to vary according to his mood on the day. But generally, he bats like a shrewd gambler, with a willingness to take risks if he thinks the odds favour him.
Nothing reflects this more than his cutting, which he does often and with a seeming sense of abandon. He cuts square, he cuts late, he uppercuts, he ramps. He cuts when he has width, he cuts when he barely has any. And sometimes he just stands there and throws his bat at the ball. He usually middles it, but sometimes he slices or edges it because he plays it so indiscriminately, and he's willing to sacrifice control for runs because he seems to believe even the edges will mostly fly over the cordon or wide of it because of how hard he goes at the ball. There will be times when he keeps getting out to the shot, but he knows there will also be times when he scores heavily with it even if he isn't always in control.
Usually Jaiswal is more selective with other shots. But on some days he just lets himself go.
Friday at the Basin Reserve was one such day. India were replying to a New Zealand total of 368, on a pitch that looked like a new-ball pitch, and their openers came out playing in entirely contrasting ways.
Even the way they survived early let-offs reflected their contrasting methods. Rahul could have been out lbw to Matt Henry, and would have been had New Zealand reviewed the on-field decision of not out. They didn't because they'd burned a review minutes earlier. But perhaps another reason was that Rahul had played this ball in a way that would give him the biggest possible chance of surviving it. The ball jagged in from the fuller side of a length, and Rahul tried very hard to ensure it would strike his pad outside off stump - he continued moving across to the off side even after the ball had struck his pad, to sow doubt in umpire Kumar Dharmasena's mind about the line of impact. He didn't give it out, and New Zealand didn't take the review that would have shown them that the ball did, in fact, strike Rahul's pad in line with the stumps.
Jaiswal had, by then, already survived a half-chance, driving away from his body at Henry when the ball wasn't quite full enough for it. But he had played the shot with complete conviction and got a thick edge that flew to the left of a diving third slip.
Sometimes you can take every measure in the world to avoid mishaps and be saved only by luck. And sometimes you can trust blindly in luck and get away with it.
That Jaiswal edge was a sneak peek of what was to come. A wild slog that cleared a desperately chasing mid-on and plopped onto the outfield. Another booming drive at a full, wide one, bursting through the hands of gully. A jab away from the body that ran away past the stumps, off the inside edge. A wild slog that took the edge and went exactly 180 degrees from its intended destination. Frequent shuffles out of his crease to the fast bowlers.
But he was also peppering the boundary with shots of ringing authority, particularly with drives either side of mid-off and ramps over the slips. The drives typically didn't come off genuine half-volleys, and the ramps didn't always require width. On one occasion, he collapsed his knees below him, leaned his upper body backwards, and met the ball directly overhead.
The margin for error for bowlers on this pitch had been shrinking steadily since the first session on day one. By going so hard at the bowling, Jaiswal was shrinking it further. Any attempt to bowl the full side of a good length and induce error, and any attempt to test the middle of the pitch, now ran the risk of leaking runs. Before New Zealand's four-man attack could work out what was happening, and what to do about it, Jaiswal had run away to a 66-ball fifty, and then scored 35 off his next 22 balls.
New Zealand eventually found a way to stay in the game by bowling wicket-to-wicket, and having keeper Tom Blundell stand up to the stumps. It took an outstanding catch from Blundell, standing up to Henry, to send Jaiswal back for 85 off 89 balls.
India made 130 in 170 balls when Jaiswal was at the crease. After his dismissal, Rahul and Devdutt Padikkal scored 29 in 70 balls to take India to stumps without further loss.
At the end of the day's play, New Zealand batter Glenn Phillips suggested his fast-bowling colleagues had perhaps tried too many things, or mis-executed their plans, in the early exchanges.
"I think our big boys will probably take it on the chin and say that they maybe missed a little bit or tried a little bit too much or more maybe from an execution perspective from what they were after," Phillips said. "And the way that we came back in that last hour of play was simplifying it down, bringing stumps into play, and understanding that that's what the pitch dictated.
"There was still a little bit in it with the new ball and maybe we got a little bit carried away for a bit long. And sometimes that is the case. You're looking for wickets and you're looking for breakthroughs, and sometimes when you try and search for it a bit much maybe you miss a little bit. And our guys are obviously old enough and brave enough to understand that the plan had to change, come in, keep it simple, and that is probably what's going to be needed for a long period of time now, that patience game, good old-fashioned long-form Test match cricket."
Most attacks take a bit of time to figure out what strategy works best on a given pitch. Jaiswal took maximum toll of the time New Zealand took to work this out on Friday, trusting in his gambler's instinct and his world-class ball-striking skills. It may not have come off on another day, but Jaiswal is the player he is because he pulls it off more often than not, and often with game-changing impact.
