MLS wild card predictions: Who will emerge from Orlando-Cincinnati, Seattle-RSL?

play
Chicago Fire FC vs. Orlando City SC - Game Highlights (1:14)

The international break may not be quite over just yet, but in MLS, attention is already returning to the club game. That's because the opening salvos of the MLS Cup playoffs begin on Thursday with the wild-card round.

Having 18 of the league's 30 teams qualify for the postseason might make for a bloated playoff field, but who doesn't love a play-in game? Thursday night will see the eighth and ninth seeds of both conferences square off for a date with the No. 1-ranked side in the East and West.

So, Orlando City vs. FC Cincinnati, Seattle Sounders vs. Real Salt Lake, how will it all play out? Who will advance? Joseph Lowery breaks down the matchups and ESPN's U.S. soccer analysts make their predictions.

Eastern Conference

8. Orlando City vs. 9. FC Cincinnati

Star attraction: There's exactly one outfield player in MLS who's been more transformational than Antoine Griezmann -- and it's Lionel Messi. Among current players with at least 1,000 minutes this year, the FIFA World Cup winner with France is the closest to Messi when it comes to goal contributions per game. Posting a staggering 1.06 combined goals and assists per 90 minutes, Orlando City's star summer signing completely changed their fortunes.

Before Griezmann, Orlando found itself near the East's basement with 14 points in 15 games and a defense hemorrhaging goals. With the former Atlético Madrid attacker in tow, the club's points per game shot up from 0.93 to 1.68, good for the sixth-best tally in MLS since the World Cup break. The Lions are still leaking goals, though -- their 78 conceded this season is tied for the second-most in league history -- but with Griezmann's passing range and goal threat, they truly can outscore their opponents and make some noise.

X-factor: It takes a serious player to nab top billing from Evander, Cincinnati's superstar No. 10, but that's exactly what Griezmann's presence in Orlando has done. Still, both teams will take pains to limit the other's elite creator. While keeping their opponent's star quiet will be a nearly impossible feat for the second- and third-worst defensive teams in MLS, that Orlando City will be paying special attention to Evander will open space for Pavel Bucha.

Outside of Evander and the team's center-back corps, no Cincinnati regular touches the ball more than Bucha. According to American Soccer Analysis, the Czechia international central midfielder takes 8.1% of his team's touches. Bucha's service even prompted manager Pat Noonan to play him as a right wingback earlier this year. Back in the center, the 28-year-old will have a chance to provide the creative touch for the visitors.

Tactical wrinkle: It's all well and good for Cincinnati to have Griezmann at the top of the scouting report and for Orlando to do the same with Evander. Slowing those players down is another matter entirely. How effectively each team accomplishes that task could decide Thursday's match.

Orlando had exactly one true center back in its squad on Decision Day. The Lions have been hurting for quality central defenders, and that pain only increased when Robin Jansson went down with a season-ending injury. Just how will interim manager Martín Perelman compensate for being perilously thin in the back?

Cincinnati, for its part, spent more on salaries for defenders than any other team this year as of the MLS Players Association's May release. Try as Noonan might, defensive stability has evaded his team. They'll need to find another level without the ball to keep Orlando's high-powered attack quiet.

Predictions

Orlando has the luxury of playing at home and will have the best player on the field in Griezmann. Between the Frenchman, Martín Ojeda, Marco Pasalic, and U.S. men's national teamer Justin Ellis, Orlando City's attacking arsenal will be too much for Cincinnati to handle. -- Lowery

Neither of these teams is very good defensively, but Cincinnati seemed to get its act together toward the end of the season. Evander vs. Griezmann should be fun, but I expect Cincinnati to come out on top. -- Jeff Carlisle

You can't overlook the form of Griezmann. He's got nine goal contributions in his past seven games for Orlando and will likely be the difference-maker in this matchup. -- Cesar Hernandez

This match feels more like a Round 1 matchup with MVP finalist Evander taking on Newcomer of the Year finalist Griezmann. Despite two good sides, Orlando should be able to capitalize on the Frenchman's magic to advance. -- Lizzy Becherano

Western Conference

8. Seattle Sounders vs. 9. Real Salt Lake

Star attraction: There was no bigger breakout star in MLS this year than Real Salt Lake striker Sergi Solans. The Spaniard has taken an atypical path, beginning in the Girona academy before heading to Oregon State, being drafted by Salt Lake, going back to school, transferring to UCLA, and now shining in MLS. Solans finished tied for eighth in non-penalty goals (15) during his rookie campaign. So impressive was the 23-year-old that RSL handed him a new contract months into the campaign.

Even with Zavier Gozo's August departure and Diego Luna 's season-ending injury, Solans managed six goals in his final eight games of the regular season. The No. 9 is a workhorse atop head coach Pablo Mastroeni's 3-4-3 attacking setup and it's hard to picture him lasting long in MLS before a European club comes knocking.

X-factor: The Sounders were getting desperate. They'd lost eight games in a row from the middle of May to the middle of August, a streak that seemed unthinkable for a team with Seattle's level of depth and experience. But with a growing injury list and a lengthy barren run, the team needed change. Enter: star striker Dejan Joveljic. In their first notable acquisition involving a transfer fee since Pedro de la Vega joined in 2024, the Sounders spent $6 million in a cash-for-player trade to snag Joveljic from Sporting Kansas City.

Immediately thrust into manager Brian Schmetzer's starting lineup, the Serbia international bagged a brace in his Seattle debut and collected four goals in his first five games. Since then? He's scored just one in six matches. Reliant on service, Joveljic doesn't have the benefit of being surrounded by a consistent or balanced attack. There's a reason his goals have come in bunches, after all.

If the Sounders manage to feed Joveljic on Thursday, they'll put themselves in the driver's seat. If not, the striker's barren run will likely continue as his team's playoff run ends.

Tactical wrinkle: In an underrated pickup, Real Salt Lake signed Canada's starting center back at the World Cup Luc de Fougerolles on loan from Fulham in the summer. The 21-year-old has been tasked with a fascinating role by Mastroeni -- one not dissimilar to how Wilfried Nancy used Steven Moreira during the Columbus Crew 's MLS Cup run in 2023. Constantly encouraged to push into the attack from his right-sided center-back spot, De Fougerolles leads all central defenders with at least 500 minutes this year in passes and touch share in the final third, as per ASA. The next closest true center back to De Fougerolles? Moreira himself.

With the Canadian eager to help RSL overload the attack, Seattle will have its hands full maintaining numerical parity in the back. But if the Sounders can stymie Salt Lake's aggressive possession positioning, they'll have chances to attack the visitors on the break.

Predictions

In the three years of MLS' current playoff format, the lower-seeded wild-card team has won just once in six tries. The odds, then, are in Seattle's favor despite Salt Lake's stronger form heading into this meeting. -- Lowery

The rosters of both teams have been in flux this season, Seattle due to injuries and RSL due to the same plus the transfer of Gozo. But of the two teams, Seattle has the experience to progress, especially in midfield with Hassani Dotson and Cristian Roldan. -- Carlisle

It's going to be a tough one for Brian Schmetzer & Co., but they have enough playoff experience to get this over the line. Keep an eye on Albert Rusnák, who has a goal and two assists in his past two appearances. -- Hernandez

The Sounders went through a difficult season, but Schmetzer's experience in the league can work to out-coach Salt Lake to earn the victory. -- Becherano