As Aston Villa prepare for life in the Championship, now that their Premier League relegation is confirmed, the temptation is to turn the clock back more than six years and consider what now appears to be the "Sliding Doors" moment in the club's recent history.
In February 2010 just five minutes had been played in the League Cup final when Manchester United's Nemanja Vidic fouled Gabby Agbonlahor as the Villa forward closed in on goal.
However, despite the denial of an obvious scoring opportunity, referee Phil Dowd satisfied himself with awarding Villa a penalty and a yellow card to the defender. James Milner subsequently scored from the spot but United eventually won 2-1.
On the Wembley sidelines, manager Martin O'Neill was aghast and later, after Villa were denied their first trophy in 14 years, said: "The referee is there to administer the laws, not make them up."
Within six months, the Irishman was gone from Villa Park. Owner Randy Lerner had previously injected £140 million into the club but opted to tighten spending on transfers and wages. Perhaps winning at Wembley might have altered the American billionaire's thinking, but with star man Milner set to be sold to Manchester City, O'Neill walked out on the eve of the 2010-11 season after three straight sixth-place finishes.
Now, having failed to find a buyer despite Villa being on the open market since May 2014 and relegation now confirmed, Lerner owns a Championship club and one that will require careful crisis management to prevent further slides down the divisions of English football.
The years since O'Neill's departure have been little but a slow-motion slide towards disaster for Villa; a litany of bad decisions and false economies that have seen a club of once-lofty ambitions descend to the inevitability of relegation.
Lerner and his advisers cannot say they had not been warned by the escapes of recent campaigns, the last four of which had seen Villa finish no higher than 15th, and yet this season's decision-making was yet more scatterbrained.
In a disastrous summer transfer window, £40m was recouped for Christian Benteke and Fabian Delph but that money -- and more -- was wasted on players like Idrissa Gueye, Jordan Amavi, Jordan Ayew, Rudy Gestede, Jordan Veretout and Adam Traore. Each have made little to no impact and none are likely to be on the shopping list of next season's Premier League clubs.
And, while a club statement last week admitted that the back-room staff face a "headcount reduction," Villa look stuck with much of that poorly-constructed squad.
Only two senior players, Kieran Richardson and Charles N'Zogbia, are out of contract this summer, leaving the next manager -- Nigel Pearson is the current favourite -- with an onerous task of reconstruction. Agbonlahor's banishment this week due to fitness issues was evidence that standards had been allowed to slip to unprofessional levels.
The next choice will be the most important of Lerner's reign. O'Neill's successors have all been, in different ways, poor fits for the club. Gerard Houllier, Alex McLeish, Paul Lambert and Tim Sherwood came and went before Remi Garde was the final, fateful misfit.
Struggling at the wrong end of the table in November, Villa needed a firefighter yet took on someone with no managerial experience in either English football or a relegation battle.
In under five months at the club, by far Garde's finest achievement was demonstrating the skill to deliver the same, shrugging post-match interview while always finding different words to do so.
The Frenchman worked with a squad put together by a recruitment process based on data and metrics that had bewildered Sherwood, and Garde had even greater problems in making those players resemble a team.
The fate of the former Lyon manager was undoubtedly sealed by Lerner's refusal to spend in the January window when the inadequacies of Sunderland, Newcastle and Norwich suggested a run to safety was still possible for Villa.
To exasperated fans, who still kept the Villa Park attendances around the 30,000 mark, it was as if the club had given up the fight to survive. Their faith and support was in no way repaid.
Though passion is often dismissed as being crucial to success in football, Garde's team often appeared to play as if they somehow felt disassociated from those paying their wages or their league position, something their manager's often flippant, sometimes glib demeanour also suggested.
The understated Garde was a diametric opposite of the excitable Sherwood, yet ended up being just as bad at organising a defence. And he regularly made the cheerless Lambert look like a positive ray of sunshine.
Garde is not alone in having being jettisoned before the ship sunk; Lerner has had to remove other ill-fated hires.
Chief executive Tom Fox's "business bingo" statements might have served him better if he were competing in "The Apprentice" rather than running a venerable football institution. He left the club last month, as did sporting director Hendrik Almstadt, who paid for recruitment failings.
Both were former Arsenal employees, as was Garde, but their choice of manager proved himself nothing like the Arsene Wenger-style visionary they envisaged.
Lerner has now left the club in the charge of new chairman Steve Hollis, a leading figure in the Midlands business scene who has taken the steps of adding "football men" to the administration.
Brian Little, manager when Villa won that last trophy, the 1996 League Cup, has joined the board, along with former Football Association chairman David Bernstein, and Adrian Bevington, another FA alum.
Down in the Championship, they and whoever succeeds Garde in the long term must right the wrongs that came about during six years of decay.
