EXCLUSIVE CONTENT
Get ESPN+

Who are the best caddies in golf, and what makes them great?

What makes a great caddie? Trust, honesty and positivity. Andrew Redington/Allsport/Getty Images

This is the hardest thing I've ever had to write. I thought it would be fun, easy and informative for the fans.

The assignment? Ask my friends and former colleagues who carry the golf bags of top golfers who the best caddies working today are.

Some of the initial responses:

"I'm not doing that."

"Why would you ask a question like that?"

"Me, me, me, me and me. Can I do that?"

There was one running theme from every caddie.

"The key to being a good caddie? Go to the first tee with a top player."

The best analogy?

"A great jockey can win the Kentucky Derby on a thoroughbred. No matter how great the jockey is, if you go to the starting gate riding a donkey, you ain't winning s---."

My counter to all those arguments was the same.

"True, but does [name deleted] win without [name deleted] on the bag?"

There were countless examples of donkeys. That caddie admitted, "You got me there."

I even got a funny answer from a multi-major-winning player when I texted him.

"What makes a great caddie? Answer: a great player. I won with [name deleted] on the bag. That ought to tell you something!"

But when pressed, he texted back, "Trust, knowledge, and maturity" makes a great caddie. Then a minute later, he added, "And thick f---ing skin."

Here's what really makes a great caddie: