In the first episode of our new video show, Caught Puji Bowled Ash, our two protagonists, the eponymous Cheteshwar Pujara and R Ashwin, long-time friends and team-mates, talk about each other's debuts for India, among other things.
Pujara: Ash, it was a nice introduction, but it could have been better, because you said I've only taken a few catches…
Ashwin: So, no, I was checking on the number of catches. How many catches have you taken in Test cricket?
Pujara: That I don't remember, but I've taken a lot [off] your bowling. That is what I should say.
Ashwin: I'll tell you what I remember. You took Steve Smith at Melbourne. Angelo Mathews was an absolute [spectacular one]. That was in Sri Lanka.
There was one [at] short leg - Shaun Marsh, Ranchi? Another good catch. Remind me of some of the others.
Pujara: There were quite a few at gully also.
Ashwin: I remember the really good ones that you've taken. You had great hands in the catching positions, Puji. I must really commend you for that. Thank you.
Let's head to your debut.
I think we were two years apart, making our debuts. Your debut was in, where was it? I'm thinking 2010. Was it Australia? I wasn't a part of the team. Was it Nathan Hauritz that you absolutely pummelled? Those are the kind of spinners you enjoyed batting against, right? Like, people who gave you enough short balls outside off stump. And kind of made errors on the fuller length.
How was your debut?
Pujara: That was in 2010 at Bangalore. I do remember getting picked for that series. First Test match was a great one, where [VVS] Laxman bhai had a partnership with Ishant [Sharma] and [Pragyan] Ojha, if I can recall it correctly.
That was some Test match, where Laxman bhai batted brilliantly. Actually, we [nearly] lost the Test match and then made a comeback. So the way Laxman batted… and after that, because he was on the field for quite some time, he had a back spasm.
Ashwin: Who did you enjoy facing the most in your debut series?
Pujara: I would say Shane Watson because there were a lot of words which were exchanged in the first innings. Not by me. Firstly, it was by him. He was sledging a lot.
Was [there] a speech culture [in the team] yet or… ?
Pujara: There was a very short speech, which was given by Veeru paaji and then- but there was a speech culture before you got into the squad.
Ashwin: You had to stand on top of a chair.
Pujara: Yeah, and then I had to give my speech - before the series started, actually. As soon as I was part of the squad, I had to stand on the chair.
Ashwin: It was a favourite MS Dhoni thing to do, right?
Pujara: Correct, yeah. That's what Mahi bhai made everyone do. And some of the younger players after my debut, I realised that they were very anxious, very nervous [about speaking].
But when I had to stand on that chair, for me it was a dream-come-true moment. I spoke for about a minute and a half. So a lot of emotions were coming out. I wasn't overwhelmed by the players who were around me, I wanted to share my thoughts. And I was very candid with the stuff I wanted to share.
So I spoke for about a minute, a minute and a half. And Mahi bhai ended up saying that this is the longest speech we have heard from a young player. So there was some confidence in what I was saying because of the amount of runs I had scored in domestic cricket.
Ashwin: You scored tons and tons of runs in domestic cricket. I remember watching you and Sitanshu Kotak bat at your home venue. I used to call you the Rajkot Raja. There used to be the Corporation Ground that you guys played on, and [one time] Tamil Nadu scored some 500 or something, and you guys just batted like a breeze, man. I mean, you were smashing it.
You scored a lot of runs in first-class cricket before getting to where you eventually did. What was the wait like? You said [that you] never expected to play for India one day. Apart from you, I think everybody else expected you to play for India!
Pujara: Yeah, initially- I never said that I didn't dream of playing for the country.
At that time, because the team was such, there was no vacancy in the playing XI. So I always thought that I belonged in the 15-member [squad], I mean, as a reserve. I always felt that I was asked this question when I was scoring a lot of runs in domestic cricket - that do you want to replace someone like Rahul Dravid? And at that time, Rahul bhai was still playing.
Ashwin: You should have just said yes, man. It would have been a great headline! You didn't say it, right?
Pujara: No, my answer was very simple. Because at that time, my genuine dream was to play with some of the legends of the game. And gain that experience of playing alongside them and learn about the game. So my answer was that I don't want to replace him, I want to play alongside Rahul bhai.
Ashwin: You don't want to replace him? You wanted to walk in together at No. 3, both of you?
Pujara: Not at No. 3. I could have batted at No. 5.
"For me, my greatest ally was the self-belief that I had. And if somebody said that I can't do something, my self-belief and resolve hardened further. So that's how I'm just made" Ashwin
Ashwin: Eventually you did replace Rahul Dravid, right?
Pujara: At No. 3. But I never thought of it. I always thought that there was a vacancy at No. 5 or 6. Not a 5, I think. I might be wrong.
Ashwin: You were never a No. 5, man.
But it's not such a bad thing to say - you know what, I love how Rahul Dravid plays the game, I'm a big fan, [but] at some stage, I want to be the next one carrying his baton forward. Saying that can [blow up]. But why is it perceived like that? You could have gone ahead and said, yes, I want that No. 3 spot.
Pujara: No, but at that time, I wasn't sure whether I'll get that opportunity to bat at No. 3. I genuinely felt that at that time, the only vacancy was at No. 5 or 6. So I was ready to do that because when I started playing domestic cricket for Saurashtra, I actually started as a No. 5 player. And then eventually, actually, Rahul bhai was the one who suggested [I bat at No. 3]. When he was captain of the Indian team, he came to Rajkot. during one of the international games, and I was playing a match for Saurashtra. I had a conversation with him.
He ended up telling Niranjan Shah [secretary of the Saurashtra Cricket Association] at that time, that [Pujara is] a prolific player for your team, why don't you make him bat up the order? And [Dravid] also told me that I should bat up the order. "No. 5 is not an ideal position for you. You are a player who has the opportunity to represent the country at some point. So why don't you bat up the order?" And that's how I started batting at No. 3 for Saurashtra.
So to answer your question whether I could have replaced Rahul bhai at that time - I never thought that.
See, there is a difference between replacing him and batting at No. 3 once he retired.
Ashwin: So you were clear in your head that once he retires, you will take up that spot. Until then, you were willing to give up that spot for him.
Pujara: Honestly, I never thought that I'll get to bat at No. 3 for the Indian team. So once you - once someone considers you as a No. 3 batter, then only you can have that choice. So for me, it was always middle order, whether it was No. 3, 4, or 5, or even 6. I didn't know where I would be batting.
Ashwin: You batted together with [Dravid] in that chase [Bengaluru 2010], right? Like, did you guys ever stumble upon this conversation: Rahul bhai, if I score more than you, I will take No. 3, you come down.
Pujara: No.
Did you ever think that you will replace Harbhajan Singh?
Ashwin: Yeah, I did.
I always imagined that. Like, I'm a big fan of Harbhajan Singh. But I always- every day I used to go and bowl spin in the nets. I used to think, "One day I must take his place."
Unfortunately that's the way life exists, man. It's human evolution. It is what it is. And nobody is permanent. And when I did that, I was well aware that somebody will come and take my spot as well one day. And that's okay.
What is one thing that [Dravid] passed on to you as a piece of wisdom that you carried with you forever?
Pujara: That was, I think that happened during 2011, when India went to South Africa. That was my first overseas tour. I again was batting at No. 5 or 6 at that time. When I went into the middle, facing Dale Steyn and Morne Morkel at their peak, I was finding it very challenging. Honestly, I felt like: do I really belong at the international level? It made me [think] that I don't have the game to play in overseas conditions. Because before that, I had- majority of my game was built on the front foot. So all my initial movements, the majority of the games which I had played, one was [against] Australia, for the A team, India A team. So I had toured to Australia, I had toured to England.
But that was my first challenge as a cricketer, and I felt: do I belong here? And then I spoke to Rahul bhai after the series, and even during the series - what can I work on which can make me a better player in overseas conditions, especially somewhere like South Africa, where there is lateral movement, there is pace and there is extra bounce? So I was struggling on my back-foot game, and that is what Rahul bhai mentioned - that you will have to work on your game against pace bowlers, especially on the back foot. And you will also have to be a little quicker with your footwork, try and get used to the pace, because in India the ball comes a little- you have a little more time. Even if you are facing 140kph, you have that time. But in South Africa, it was challenging.
So that is one thing which I worked on. And eventually, when I went in 2013, things turned around and I had good success. But that, you know, that part of improving my back-foot game, working a little bit on my technique, has helped me immensely.
Ashwin's Test debut
Ashwin: My debut was quite an interesting one, Puji, because I went on the Champions League [tour] to South Africa. And I had a great time in the IPL 2010, 2011. And I was probably at the- you know, you can call that as your most enjoyable time of your career, or your life. And I was really expanding through the domestic cricket circuit.
We played a Rest-of-India game at Jaipur [Irani Cup, 2010], where Yuvraj Singh was the captain, and it was against Mumbai. I got Rohit [Sharma], Ajinkya [Rahane], and a couple of others [out]. I got a fifer in that game at Jaipur.
And I was waiting for my- I thought my Test debut would come. A lot of noise was made around the fact that I was a T20 bowler, a one-dimensional white-ball bowler. But after that game that I played for Rest of India - it was a huge bashathon, I think Yuvraj got a double-hundred in the second innings or something, if I'm not wrong. Like 600 [team total], and I got a five-for. So he came and told me, I've seen you. He was my first Challenger Trophy captain as well. So he told me, I thought you were a good white-ball bowler, but after seeing this, I think you will make your Test debut very soon.
Pujara: But for you, was there a dilemma whether- because, since you were picked in the white-ball circuit first, you had played the IPL, you were part of India's ODI World Cup, and India had a great World Cup as well. So did you ever think that you will eventually play for the Indian Test team, or you thought, no, you just want to first carry on with the white-ball opportunity you have? Or what was the thought?
Ashwin: Look, I think inside me, I mean, several times you can- people can have another view from the outside. But for me, my greatest ally was the self-belief that I had. And if somebody said that I can't do something, my self-belief and resolve hardened further. So that's how I'm just made. It's unfortunate [for some other people] that I'm made like that, but for me, it's a great attribute to have.
Like, I started, I turned [into] as offspinner-batter in 2003-04. I came back from the NCA [National Cricket Academy]. We were in the NCA together.
"The kind of confidence MS had in me at that early stage of the career was quite amazing. Because when he was the captain [in the IPL], I played. And then he got injured, I didn't play" Ashwin
Pujara: We were competitors, weren't we? You were [batting] in the top order.
Ashwin: Yeah, I was opening the batting. I made a couple of hundreds in the practice games at the NCA as well.
Pujara: Not many people know that actually [at] Under-17 [level] you were ahead of me [as a batter].
Ashwin: You were still a No. 3 batter then. I was an opener.
Pujara: Okay, yeah. But there was some competition, isn't it?
Ashwin: My competition was with Rohit Sharma. To say that now is a bit out of bounds. But yeah, at that point of time, Rohit eventually replaced me. I went to the NCA, and when I came back, I started bowling offbreak in a game where our team was struggling in club cricket in Chennai.
But ever since I took my bowling seriously, I played U-22 as an offspinner for Tamil Nadu. I used to just love picking up five-wicket hauls, and I loved bowling a lot, which is when I realised I could make it. Because as a batter, I always felt like I had the skills but I was competing with a lot of people. But once I turned [into] an offspinner, I suddenly found joy in bowling that I never found with the bat.
In my mind, I never had any doubts that I will one day play for India as an offspin bowler. And for me, picking up five-wicket hauls gave me a lot of joy. And building up my career as a spinner in Chennai club cricket, I used to pick five-wicket hauls in every single game. So for me, in my mind, I had no doubts. Then it came down to proving other people wrong every single day.
Pujara: Were you told in advance that you will make your [Test] debut?
Ashwin: No, I wasn't.
Funnily enough, I called the chairman of selectors, [Kris] Srikkanth. There was this [England] tour that was happening. And I think Harbhajan Singh injured himself and he flew back to India. And they were looking for a replacement. So I thought, okay, maybe as an offbreak to offbreak [replacement], I would go. If there is an opportunity, I am one of those kinds who will say, okay, I'll take the opportunity. I'm happy to succeed or fail.
And then I didn't get picked. I was not in the squad. I called him and asked, what more do I need to work on? Typically, Cheeka being Cheeka, he just said, you know, you wait for your chance. I know when to give you a break, you have to wait for your chance. There are enough spinners in the team. [Amit] Mishra is there. Ojha is there. So I said, yeah, yeah, that's fine, sir. If there is something I need to work on, I'll definitely work on it. And eventually, I think when we came back, I don't think we had a great series [in England]. I went and played the ODI series. Did very well in the ODI series in England. Came back and got my opportunity [in Tests].
And I think I keep getting confused because my Test jersey number is 271. Umesh Yadav also made his debut in the same Test match. Until we finished, we both used to get confused who was 271, who was 272. My cap was given by Lachhibhai [Laxman]. And yeah, he's got great, lucky hands, man.
Pujara: And so, what was [your] speech like? And were you outspoken like [you are now]? Even when you made your debut?
Ashwin: I've had conversations with Sachin [Tendulkar] paaji on spin bowling. I've also made it a point to tell Sachin paaji that what I'm saying is right over what he said was right! And we've had some interesting conversations. But paaji really enjoyed it, I think. He's not someone who believes in, you know, I say whatever is right and the other person shouldn't contest it. He's very- he had deep knowledge of the game. I enjoyed conversing with him. We had conversations on spin bowling and all that. He used to stand at mid-off.
And Dhoni being the skipper, I had quite a relationship with him coming from CSK [Chennai Super Kings].
So my Test debut was quite a memorable one. Ojhi [Ojha] picked up six in the first [innings]. I picked up six in the second. A very memorable series for me. I got six-for and a three-for. I got a nine-for. Got Man of the Match. Went back to Chennai. Got married. Came back, played the [next] Test match [in Kolkata] the next morning.
And the last game- so Lachhi bhai got 160 [176] at Kolkata, right? And I was still batting very well. I used to get a lot of runs. I made 1000-800 runs in Chennai in club cricket and got 60 wickets and all that. But I batted in the middle order [in club cricket]. So when I went in to bat [in the Tests], first game, I got a duck, got caught down the leg side to Daren Sammy. It was high pressure, man. That was the maximum pressure I'd felt in life.
And the second Test I walked in to bat when Lachhi bhai was batting. We were about to declare. It was, like, overcast and all that in Kolkata. I made three or four runs. And then they declared quickly. So I came and said, what is this, they've declared? And I was like- obviously, I wasn't this comfortable with everybody [then]. And then I went in and then Veeru, Virender Sehwag, was there and he was like, I saved you. I asked, what happened? This guy was bowling- was it Kemar Roach? I can't remember who it was.
And he said, "I saved you, because in this darkness, the ball could have hit you. So I protected you and that's why we declared."
Inside my mind, I was fuming! And truth as it be told, the next Test match [Mumbai], I got an opportunity to bat. And once I finished batting, Veeru was the first one to come up to me. "You bat well." So it's like, yes man, Veeru pa, in the last game, you said you saved me. I felt very bad. "Ash, I haven't seen your batting at all. How would I know?"
And that was good fun. I got a hundred and all that. It was great fun.
Pujara: When you made your debut, second innings India was trailing by 95 runs and MS asked you to bowl with the new ball. Was it something which was already decided or was it because of the IPL, where you have bowled with the new ball?
Ashwin: Possibly that was in MS' head. With MS, right, I almost got used to the fact that he will make these instinctive calls. He is not someone who will say [in advance], "You will open tomorrow, you will do this." I mean, he's very spontaneous. And even when I made my IPL debut, he was very similar.
It's amazing, man. The kind of confidence he [had] in me at that early stage of the career was quite amazing. Because when he was the captain [in the IPL], I played. And then he got injured, I didn't play. Suresh [Raina] was the captain, I didn't play. And then [Dhoni] came back from injury and I played again. I was not even in the squad when he was not there as a captain. When Suresh was captain, I was out of the squad.
"When I went into the middle, facing Dale Steyn and Morne Morkel at their peak, I was finding it very challenging. Honestly, I felt like: do I really belong at the international level?" Pujara
I think what [Dhoni] liked - I eventually perceived this, he's not going to communicate this also - is the fact that I picked my own fields. I was courageous enough and I delivered to the field that I wanted. And he very rarely had to interfere when I went about my business. So when we- Murali [Muthiah Muralidaran] and I, we were playing in a game, two offspinners playing in an IPL game, oh my god, that looks like stone age now. We don't do that. Even one offie playing in T20 cricket is non-existent now.
So we were in the huddle and we were going in to play against Mumbai Indians and he just said, "You bowl with the new ball." And it's like, that's it. He turned and went back. And very similar in this [Test] also. He just asked me to start from the other side. I was bowling from the current Virat Kohli Pavilion side, whatever. So I bowled from there and I had bowled a lot with the new ball in league cricket.
Pujara: So you were ready. You picked up nine wickets in your debut game. Do you remember a particular wicket which you liked the most?
Ashwin: Let me try to trace these nine wickets. The first innings was Darren Bravo…
Pujara: Also, there was a carrom ball which you-
Ashwin: Yeah, Marlon Samuels.
Pujara: So is there any specific wicket which you remember?
Ashwin: So my first wicket was actually a good one because I- with the action [I had at] that time, I used to have a slight [bit] more hyperextension, and I knew with the new ball I could get the ball to drift away.
Conventional wisdom is to get the ball to drift into a left-hander. But I used to get it to drift out and Kieran Powell [in the second innings] drove it and [Gautam] Gambhir juggled and took the catch.
And that was actually the start- because it was the second-day evening, if I'm not wrong.
We had fumbled the innings with the bat. And I got the first wicket there. And generally my template has been that if I get two top-order wickets, I kind of knew how to close out a five-wicket haul. So when I got that wicket, and I dismissed Bravo next day lbw, if I'm not wrong. And then got Samuels and I got a five-wicket haul.
Pujara: Coming back to the IPL, you mentioned that when Suresh was the captain, you didn't play. But did you ever have a conversation with him [asking] why you weren't part of the squad? Did you ask questions? You always, you're outspoken, you always go and ask questions. Did you manage to ask him at any point?
Ashwin: Not really, but I did ask questions. I mean, in the sense that, obviously, I like clarity. Like, I'm sure everybody likes clarity. When you're not doing well or when you are out of the team or somebody makes- eventually, it's the leader that makes a decision, be it a corporate or a cricket team. The leader makes a decision. But what really helps me is feedback.
But a lot of people can feel challenged [when asked] about it, which I eventually discovered - that I can be a little challenging while asking these questions, because they feel uncomfortable. The answer is not ready-made.
I didn't ask Suresh.
I went for a game, CSK vs RCB at Bangalore, and I bowled the 13th, 15th, 18th, and 20th overs as an offbreak bowler. And I had three overs, 18 runs [23 runs]. And the last over, Mark Boucher just took me down. I didn't have a great game. I put a catch down at sweeper cover off Murali's bowling and we lost the game.
I was just [there] for the picking, man. I mean, I was there for the [scapegoating]. Somebody had to be dropped. We were not winning games. So I got done away with. But what was shocking for me was, they discarded me out of the squad.
Because I had a really good run-in. And no answers given. So I picked up the phone. VB Chandrasekhar is not there anymore. I do miss him even now. Unfortunately, he's no more. He was the CEO of the team or the director. I can't remember the post. I called him and said, Sir, why did you leave me out of the squad? I need an explanation. I said, Sir, is there a reason? Could I work on something? Because anybody can have a bad game.
He's like, let me speak to the coach and get back to you. And he never got back to me. And two days later, I made sure I called again. And this time he's like, I don't have an answer yet. If I have an answer, I'm obliged to answer you. Like, very curt. But then once MS came back, I got- and then VB told me that MS has more confidence, he knows how to use you. So I think that's why you're back in the squad. So, yeah, I didn't ask Suresh because I just didn't get the access to do it. I think it was [Stephen] Fleming who was supposed to give me an explanation. Sometimes in IPL, the coaches need to handle this. I did express my disappointment to Fleming for not communicating it to me. He took it well.
Pujara: Coming back to your debut [Test] game - one takeaway from your debut game? Because, see, many young players who represent the country, some end up playing so many Test matches for the Indian team across the formats. [Is there] one thing which you learn after making your debut for the Indian team which can help you throughout your career?
Ashwin: So, look, when I made my debut, I was very confident of picking up wickets, right? And I had prepared really well, planned very well for every batter. But when I went in to bat, sometimes- this is one thing that I figured out a lot later as a cricketer. That a lot of planning while you're batting doesn't necessarily work. You can plan and work at the net, but not in the game. So the one learning I took away from that game and would probably tell anybody is: batting is a reaction sport.
You keep yourself blank. Just go out there and look to hit the ball. I was going there to, you know, telling myself, you know, Test debut, let me play a ball here. If I had an intent to score runs, I would have put that ball away on the leg side. So that is the one thing. Bowling is action. Batting is reaction. To compartmentalise that.
It took a bit of time for me. And I think it happened with [Ravindra] Jadeja as well. He eventually, when he figured it out, I think he cracked the batting code as a batter.
Anyway, that question is quite valuable to ask you as well. Anything that you would like to change?
Pujara: No, nothing. Because I had a good debut. I mean, I had scored runs in the second innings. One thing I might have wanted is to get a hundred in the first game itself. So that mental, you know, that, how do you call it? As a Test player, you always want to get to that first hundred. That came, for me, quite late. And I had the opportunity to get to 100. I was batting on 72 when I got out.
So, that is only one thing I might have wanted to change.
