Mahfijul Islam's first steps in Test cricket come with hard lessons

Mahfijul Islam found it tough against the new ball AFP/Getty Images

For all his struggles against the genuine pace and bounce of the South Africa pace attack, Mahfijul Islam managed to stay put for 92 deliveries. His 32 in the second innings seemed defiant but only delayed Bangladesh's top-order crash on the fourth afternoon.

The innings wasn't necessarily assuring and perhaps didn't make a lot of difference to how Bangladesh shaped up at stumps. It did, however, serve as an eye-opening experience.

Mahfijul was troubled by Kagiso Rabada and Co on the fourth afternoon. At times it got ugly, like when Mahfijul ducked into a half-volley from Rabada, which ended up hitting his thigh pad. There were knocks to his midriff and fingers. One of the rising deliveries even broke Mahfijul's bat.

After working hard not to fall to the fast bowlers and just managing it just about, Mahfijul fell to a jaffa from offspinner Simon Harmer. A little later, Bangladesh lost Towhid Hridoy too and finished the day on 100 for 5. They were 57 runs away from making South Africa bat again, otherwise, they would become one of the very few teams to lose a match by an innings, despite scoring 400 runs in their first innings.

Bangladesh batted really well earlier in this game, but that was mainly down to three separate acts. Tanzid Hasan struck 67, before Towhid Hridoy and Litton Das lifted them to a very impressive first-day score of 327 for 6. The visitors ended up on 400 all out, with both Hridoy and Litton hitting centuries. But among their top seven, Mahfijul, Mominul Haque and Mushfiqur Rahim fell for ducks.

In Bangladesh's batting order, the baton has certainly shifted from the old guard. Mushfiqur is the only one left from those days. Hridoy's superb start suggests a generational shift, but inconsistency from the likes of Najmul Hossain Shanto and Tanzid hold things back. Litton, for all his form and class, bats too low and has to keep wickets as well.

Mahfijul came into the picture as an opening back-up to Shadman Islam, who got injured in the second Test against West Indies. The original plan was to give Mahmudul Hasan Joy a comeback in Shadman's place. Joy's century in South Africa from the previous tour was in his favour, but then he fell ill. Mahfijul was the next man in line, having scored three centuries in the domestic first-class competition this season. He also made 112 runs including a fifty in Bangladesh Emerging Team's two unofficial Tests on their tour to South Africa in August this year.

Mahfijul playing the first Test was still a bit of a surprise. Opener Mohammad Naim, who was also picked on the back of recent first-class form, was the more internationally experienced cricketer among the two.

Mahfijul fell for a golden duck on the first day, but he is also the first overseas opener to debut in South Africa in 11 years. He is the fourth Asian opener to debut in South Africa, a country with the reputation of handing out tough initiations for openers generally. After the first-innings duck, there was the dreaded pair looming.

Tanzid, his partner, was questioned over not facing the first ball in the press conference on the first day. This time he did take strike and said that Mahfijul wanted to take the first ball. Rabada bowled that over and before Marco Jansen followed up by rapping high on Mahfijul's pads. Mahfijul only mustered a leg-bye later in the over.

Rabada felt he had had his man when Mahfijul missed a flick on the first ball of his next over. However, Mahfijul got an inside edge, which the on-field umpire missed, and survived through DRS. His first boundary was edged over the slip cordon, before Wiaan Mulder dropped a one-handed attempt at first slip.

Rabada aimed at the pads in his next over and got one to whistle past Mahfijul's nose in the over after. The bat-breaker came in the same over, but then when Mahfijul left the fifth ball, he seemed pleased with the decision. Rabada just snarled back at him.

Rabada and Jansen had bowled 25 dots out of 28 balls to Mahfijul in their combined first spell.

Mulder then got Mahfijul to inside edge one to the boundary, while Dane Paterson got one to sneak through and hit the pad, just outside the line of off-stump. It took till the 16th over for Mahfijul to crack one with some power, even then he could only find the point fielder. He struck two more fours, but neither too convincing, before slog-sweeping Harmer for his first six.

Harmer, ever the smart operator, was just drawing Mahfijul out of the crease to get that bat-pad gap bigger. Shortly afterwards, he brought him down to drive towards mid-off, got the ball through the gate to hit the top of off-stump. It was a classic trap but quite clear that Mahfijul wasn't paying much attention to it. South Africa's pace and bounce had kept him busy all this time.

This is where Mahfijul's selection brings up questions. This was only his 20th first-class match, and possibly the first time he has faced high-quality express pace before this innings was in the practice match against the touring West Indies side last month. He lasted all of eight balls against Kemar Roach and Jayden Seales. A bit more grounding against fast bowling, particularly playing for Bangladesh A or other representative teams, may have prepared Mahfijul better.

He is one of many concerns in the Bangladesh team. The fact that he has been picked as an opener in Johannesburg indicates that the Bangladesh set-up sees long-term promise in him. He needs to improve a whole lot if he is to live up to it.