Javier Báez homered and doubled for the Mets, who began the day four games behind NL East leader Atlanta and 4 ½ from the second wild card.
“You just have to come back the next day and try again,” Báez said. “That’s why you go by day by day, pitch by pitch. It’s all you can control. We’ll see what happens this next week.”
Chisholm drove a 97 mph fastball from Jeurys Familia (9-4) into the upper deck seats for his 15th homer. Chisholm also had an RBI grounder in the sixth.
“I’ve faced Familia before, I know he throws hard,” Chisholm said. “I was just looking for a pitch up. He got it up and I got all of it.”
The blast was measured at 402 feet, a distance Chisholm and Miami manager Don Mattingly questioned.
“That was a beautiful swing and I’m not sure I haven’t seen a ball go further than that here in this building,” Mattingly said.
“You feel pretty good with Báez coming in to hit there and the way he’s swinging the bat,” manager Luis Rojas said. “It didn’t happen. We expect the guys to be better as we move forward from this game.”
Dylan Floro pitched a perfect ninth for his ninth save.
The Marlins tied it at 2 in the seventh around three infield hits and a throwing error by reliever Brad Hand.
Starter Marcus Stroman was lifted after allowing Sandy León’s one-out single and Hand gave up Isan Díaz’s single. Mets catcher James McCann then threw out pinch-runner Alex Jackson at third when a pitch caromed to the backstop, with Díaz advancing to second on the play.
Pinch-hitter Lewis Brinson beat out a dribbler near the mound and Hand’s throw got past Alonso at first base, allowing a run to score.
Stroman allowed one run, four hits and struck out seven in 6 1/3 innings. After sitting out last season, Stroman became the first pitcher to reach 30 starts in 2021 with his outing Thursday.
“I do everything I can to put my team in the position to win when I’m out there,” Stroman said. “When the manager calls me, I’m done.”
Báez hit a two-out double and scored on two wild pitches from Miami starter Jesús Luzardo to give New York a 1-0 lead in the first.
The Mets increased their advantage on Báez’s 29th homer in the third. He hit Luzardo’s curveball over the wall in center field, admiring the 438-foot shot before he rounded the bases.
The two hits by Báez were the only ones allowed by Luzardo in 5 2/3 innings. He struck out eight and walked four.
Before the game, both teams stood alongside their dugouts during a moment of silence and brief video tribute remembering the 20th anniversary of the 9/11 attacks in New York, Washington, D.C., and Pennsylvania. Members of the South Florida rescue team, which participated in the recovery effort following the attacks, also were recognized.
Mets: C Tomás Nido (left thumb strain) could play in rehab games at Triple-A Syracuse this weekend, Rojas said.
Marlins: RHP Pablo López (right rotator cuff strain) has been playing catch with the anticipation of progressing to a bullpen session in the coming days.
Marlins: LHP Trevor Rogers (7-6, 2.52) starts the opener of a three-game series at Atlanta Friday. Rogers, Miami’s NL All-Star representative, has not won since June 10.
MLB playoffs 2021: Best moments from ALCS Game 1 between Boston Red Sox and Houston Astros
The Boston Red Sox and Houston Astros meet again in the ALCS with a trip to the World Series on the line.
Stephen A.: Dodgers-Braves should have been a divisional series
Stephen A. Smith implores MLB to change its playoff format after the Giants drew the Dodgers in the first round despite both teams eclipsing 100 wins.
Milwaukee Brewers seeking answers for Christian Yelich's hitting struggles
Brewers president of baseball operations David Stearns says nobody has been able to figure out the cause of Christian Yelich's hitting struggles over the past couple of seasons.
Atlanta Braves to start Max Fried in Game 1 of National League Championship Series
Max Fried, who pitched six shutout innings with nine strikeouts in Atlanta's Game 2 win over Milwaukee in the NLDS, will start against the Dodgers in Game 1 of the NLCS on Saturday.
Thursday night's NFL and MLB endings cost bettors big money
The final results of Thursday's primetime NFL and MLB games were equal parts dramatic and costly for bettors with wagers on those particular events.
Houston Astros ace Lance McCullers Jr. left off ALCS roster against Boston Red Sox
Right-hander Jake Odorizzi had been added to the Astros' roster for the ALCS, replacing ace Lance McCullers Jr., who suffered forearm tightness in his last start and is still being evaluated.